June 3, 2008
No Pride Idol this week, folks. Can you stand it?
I can't. I'm ready to judge! Maybe I'll just show up and judge karaoke.
It's amazing how different the contestants sound when I listen to the clips on playback, without the noisy crowd drowning out so much. Here are some quick thoughts:
Lance: Listening to him sing back When You Say You Love Me was sort of a revelation. His performance is easily the best, technically speaking.
I understand why he chose the song, but it's not necessarily a good reason. More than anything, it sounds old-fashioned. Nothing about Josh Groban's music is modern. Lance needs to pick something that will sound and feel current. There's also a slight pinched quality to his voice that I think comes from trying so hard. If he relaxes, he may be able to go far.
Zea: Madonna's Crazy for You is clearly out of Zea's range. Not that she can't sing it, but she's affecting a higher tone than what her voice is comfortable with through much of the song. It's also just not a great choice. Too slow.
I think Zea should just go all out and sex it up a bit! Make it fun.
Shelia: Why do I just like Shelia so much? I think it's because more than anyone left, her personality comes through when she sings. It's not technically perfect, but I can feel her heart when she performs. And I can feel it listening back to her performance.
All she needs to work on -- a bit -- is her confidence. Trust in herself and that she can do it.
David: He's really rebounded from the first week. David's got a fun stage presence, and he clearly seems more comfortable as this progresses. Listening back, all I'd say is be careful to not strain your voice. Let the song flow from you; don't force it. At times, he seems to be pushing a bit too hard.
I'm still a bit sad that Michele is gone. (Sniff.) I just think this was the wrong venue for her voice. There's a really pretty delicacy in her voice that I love, and I still hear it in her last performance.
Seriously -- listen to her take on the Cure's Just Like Heaven. Not too bad, really. In fact, listen to all her performances. I think her challenge was what I said during judging: figuring out a way to power up without losing the sweet magic of her voice or veering out of her range. Guava Lamp's noise level was too much for her, and I think we lost a unique talent too early. Sigh.
But on to the finals! Who's your favorite? Who will make it? What do you think of the clips on the website?
Of course, I believe you all know Shelia "G" is my favorite. :) That said, I believe the final outcome will be between Shelia and David. They both have what I hear as a bit of roughness in their voice and I personally like it. Is there a prize for 2nd place or runner up? The clips on the website are great. Much love to all. Let's also remember to have a great Pride month.
well...with that said...i think that LANCE should be in the final 2! ugh! ;) lol
